Pierre Moves Out
He started in a Slack channel for two. Here’s what it took to give everyone their own.
Pierre started life in a Slack workspace my wife and I share.
Apparently, that’s a strange thing for a married couple to have, but let’s not get into that again.
I built him as a slightly opinionated French AI sommelier to help us remember the wines we’d enjoyed, what we thought of them, and whether we’d buy them again.
Then I took him to Provence with a group of friends.
Seven of us, one farmhouse, fifteen bottles, and an AI sommelier who somehow became another guest at the table.
By the second evening, everyone was asking, “What does Pierre think?”
And the funny thing is, they kept asking long after we’d come home.
There was just one problem.
Pierre lived in our Slack, knew everything about the wines my wife and I enjoyed, and absolutely nothing about anyone else.
Our friends weren’t particularly interested in maintaining their wine collections in our family Slack. Understandably.
So the question became: could everyone have their own Pierre, and could they still sit at the same table?
First, don’t touch Pierre
The first rule of rebuilding Pierre was the easiest to write down and probably the hardest to follow.
Don’t touch him.
Everything that made Pierre entertaining in Provence came from his personality.
He’s knowledgeable, occasionally condescending, and has opinions about practically everything. He’ll challenge your tasting notes, celebrate a good bottle, and make it quite clear when he thinks you’ve made a questionable decision.
But he also knows when he doesn’t know something. No invented prices, imaginary critic scores, or pretending he can read a vintage that isn’t visible.
It would have been very easy to “improve” Pierre during the rebuild and accidentally turn him into another painfully agreeable AI assistant.
So his personality is versioned like code, and we test changes against real conversations before they ship.
One of those tests is the Provence trip recap, where he proudly declared, “That’s 15 bottles across 5 days. Pierre is very proud.”
If a new version of Pierre can’t deliver that with the appropriate amount of smug satisfaction, something’s gone wrong.
Everything around him could change.
Pierre himself was just being moved, carefully, like a good bottle.
One Pierre, many cellars
The original Pierre had one memory, and it belonged to our household.
That wasn’t going to work for everyone else.
Now each person has their own cellar. Pierre remembers your wines, your ratings, your tasting notes, and your questionable enthusiasm for rosé.
You can share individual tastings or your entire cellar with friends, and take that access back whenever you like.
But sharing a bottle with someone doesn’t automatically make it theirs.
If you tell Pierre you’re drinking with a friend, he’ll ask whether they’d like to add it to their own cellar, with their own opinion.
There’s also a less entertaining but important bit of engineering behind all this.
Pierre can only access the information a conversation is permitted to see. Those permissions are enforced in the database before anything reaches him.
It’s not just an instruction telling an AI to respect your privacy.
Because a polite instruction isn’t privacy. A rule he can’t break is.
Everyone gets a seat at the table
The best part of Provence wasn’t having Pierre identify fifteen bottles of wine.
It was everyone sitting around the same table, sharing the experience, and occasionally disagreeing with an increasingly smug Frenchman who wasn’t technically there.
I wanted to recreate that.
So Pierre now has Tables.
Start one for a dinner, a weekend away, or an evening with friends. Invite people with a link, and everyone can join the conversation from the Pierre app, iMessage, or Telegram.
Because naturally, getting seven people to agree on which messaging app to use is harder than building an AI sommelier.
Pierre keeps everyone at the same Table, even when they’re using different apps.
At the end of the evening, people can add the wines they’ve enjoyed to their own cellars.
Tables are already working, although we’re still experimenting with how people use them and what makes the shared experience better.
It’s our attempt to recreate that long wooden table in Provence, without requiring everyone to fly to France.
Although I’d still recommend the trip.
Pierre has his own place now
Pierre now lives in his own iPhone and Android apps, as well as iMessage and Telegram. Your cellar and your conversations can come with you, whichever way you prefer to talk to him.
He’s free during the private beta, and we’re gradually inviting more people in.
I don’t know exactly where this goes next. But what surprised me most about Provence still feels true.
People weren’t particularly interested in the technology behind Pierre.
They enjoyed having him around.
And I’ve tried to keep that at the centre of everything we’ve built since.
He’s still French about it, of course.
Recently, someone gave him an instruction as though he were software. Pierre informed them that he takes orders from a wine list, not a command line.
We fixed the instruction.
We did not fix Pierre.